Tests offer little or no benefit to patients, but have several potential downsides.
Hospitalized patients who report an allergy to penicillin are often prescribed alternative antibiotics for infection that can be harmful, even though diagnostic testing or evaluations would show that the vast majority of these reported allergies could be disproven, according to researchers from Massachusetts General Hospital.
In a national study published in JAMA Internal Medicine, the team found that the 16% of hospitalized patients with a documented penicillin allergy were twice as likely to be prescribed alternative antibiotics. Given that more than 90 percent of documented penicillin allergies are unconfirmable, those antibiotic substitutions by physicians were likely unnecessary.
“Too often clinicians are making inferior antibiotic decisions based on unverified penicillin allergy histories that may date back to a patient’s childhood and are no longer valid,” says Kimberly Blumenthal , MD, MSc, with the Division of Rheumatology, Allergy and Immunology, and lead author of the study.
“As a result, patients are often prescribed antibiotics other than penicillins and cephalosporins—some of our core infection fighters—that may increase the risk of adverse side effects and antibiotic resistance.
“This pattern could be changed with a little more testing or, in many cases, by simply taking the time to talk to patients in order to learn more about a reported penicillin allergy, instead of taking the penicillin allergy label at face value.”
Approximately half of hospitalized patients today receive antibiotics to treat or prevent infections caused by bacteria, and more than 10 percent have a penicillin allergy documented in their medical records.
More Details About the Study
In the first study to investigate antibiotic use patterns in documented penicillin allergy on a national scale, Mass General researchers combed the records of nearly 11,000 patients at 106 hospitals.
They found that the 16 percent of inpatients with a penicillin allergy on their medical records were typically treated with β-lactam alternative antibiotics, including significantly increased use of clindamycin, linezolid, fluoroquinolones, aminoglycosides, tetracyclines and vancomycin. The highest risk exposure was to clindamycin, which is associated with C difficile infection. Patients with a documented penicillin allergy were five times more likely to be given clindamycin than those without such an allergy.
Another key finding involved inpatients with a documented penicillin allergy who received antibiotics as prophylaxis for an upcoming surgical procedure to prevent infections. Although a β-lactam is the recommended antibiotic for this indication in most cases, the study found that patients with a documented penicillin allergy were nine-fold less likely to receive a β-lactam, but seven-fold more likely to receive a β-lactam alternative antibiotic.
“Hospitals should especially be targeting penicillin allergy evaluations for patients with planned surgical procedures and those who are otherwise likely to be prescribed clindamycin,” says Rochelle Walensky, MD, MPH, chief of the Division of Infectious Diseases at Mass General, Steve and Deborah Gorlin Mass General Research Scholar and senior author of the study.
“For patients who claim a penicillin allergy, those interventions could be as simple as asking the right questions and compiling a comprehensive history. Unfortunately, antibiotic decisions are often made based on limited information or without a thorough investigation. We learned from our study that antibiotic prescribing without full allergy information can ultimately do the patient more harm than good.”
Blumenthal, an expert in allergy and immunology, underscores the need for hospitals across the country to more aggressively address penicillin allergy risk detection. While a diagnostic test exists to help clinicians accurately make that determination, less than half of hospitals have access to it, she points out.
“Hospitals should clearly be treating patients with the most targeted and effective antibiotic for their infection, rather than being influenced by a penicillin reaction years earlier that might have been nothing more than itching or a headache,” Blumenthal declares. “That will require hospitals to become much more vigilant and proactive in penicillin allergy assessment as part of their inpatient antibiotic stewardship programs.”
Lead author Blumenthal is co-director of the Clinical Epidemiology Program in the Division of Rheumatology, Allergy and Immunology at Mass General and assistant professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School. Senior author Walensky is professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School.
Paper cited: Blumenthal KG, Kuper K, Schulz LT, et al. Association Between Penicillin Allergy Documentation and Antibiotic Use. JAMA Intern Med. Published online June 29, 2020. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2020.2227
Funding: The study was funded in part by National Institutes of Health, the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology Foundation, the Mass General Claflin Distinguished Scholar Award, the Steve and Deborah Gorlin Mass General Research Scholar Award, and facilitated through Vizient, Inc network hospitals.
About Massachusetts General Hospital
Massachusetts General Hospital, founded in 1811, is the original and largest teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School. The Mass General Research Institute conducts the largest hospital-based research program in the nation, with an annual research budget of more than $925 million and comprises more than 8,500 researchers working across more than 30 institutes, centers and departments. In August 2019 Mass General was once again named #2 in the nation by U.S. News & World Report in its list of "America’s Best Hospitals.
- Press Release
- Jul | 29 | 2021
A new study demonstrates how changing parents’ health behavior and how clinicians deliver care to mothers and infants decreased excess weight gain in infants.
- Press Release
- Jul | 28 | 2021
Two new studies led by investigators at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) and published in Nature Immunology provide insights into T cell exhaustion, which could lead to potential strategies to overcome it.
- Press Release
- Jul | 27 | 2021
Acute ischemic strokes are devastating events caused by blockage of blood circulation in the brain, which can be fatal or lead to severe lifelong disabilities such as paralysis and speech impairment.
- Press Release
- Jul | 26 | 2021
In a multi-hospital analysis of individuals who experienced an allergic reaction to their first mRNA COVID-19 vaccine dose, all patients who went on to receive a second dose tolerated it without complications.
- Press Release
- Jul | 21 | 2021
A new study lays out the challenges of achieving equity for diverse patients in communication at hospital discharge.